Silicon SidelineSILICON SIDELINE

Their view

Midterm History vs. Frontier Tech: What Could Tuesday's Vote Do to AI Stocks?

Voters pick Congress today. We pulled the game film on every big midterm flip, from the railroad era to the FAANG era, and lined up what AI voices say.

Silicon Sideline ·

Around the league

Pull up a chair, fans. Today the league votes on a new rules committee.

That's Congress. It writes the rulebook, holds hearings and can call coaches in to testify under oath. The commissioner, the President, keeps his veto whistle no matter what happens tonight. But when the committee flips from one party to the other, the whole league starts asking the same question: does the game change?

So let's do what any good coach does before a big game. We'll watch old film. Every time the committee flipped, what happened to the scoreboard? And what happened to that era's hottest new players, the frontier technology of the day? Railroads were the AI of the 1870s. Radio and cars had their turn. So did electronics, personal computers, chips and the internet.

One warning before the film rolls. History is a record book, not a playbook. We aren't predicting anything.

Play 1: The long record

Here's the headline stat. Measured from the last close before Election Day to one year later, the S&P 500 (and before 1957 its predecessor, the S&P 90) was higher after all 20 midterms from 1946 to 2022. The average gain was about 14.8% (Dave Manuel, analysis of Yahoo Finance closes, 21 Oct 2026). Other studies line up:

The catch: that's 20 games, a tiny sample. The window matters too, and interest rates, recessions and earnings were doing a lot of the work. Dave Manuel notes the 2006 window ended in November 2007, a month after the market peaked and just before the 2008 crash.

Play 2: The game film, flip by flip

How to read the markers: ▲ means the S&P was higher one year after the vote. ▼ would mean it was lower (none of these years were). A year with no arrow is outside Dave Manuel's 1946-2022 record. All markers use the S&P one year later, from Dave Manuel's figures (21 Oct 2026).

When Democrats took BOTH chambers

▲ S&P one year later: up 33.0% (Dave Manuel)

1954 (Eisenhower, Republican, in the White House). Democrats took the House and Senate. The S&P 90 rose 33.0% over the next year. That's the best post-midterm year in Dave Manuel's 1946-2022 record (Pepperstone has +33.2%).

Frontier tech then: television and the first big computers. In April 1954, RCA brought out the CT-100, the first color TV set to be mass-produced (about 4,400 were made). IBM had announced its first commercial scientific computer, the IBM 701, in 1952. Remington Rand sold the UNIVAC I, the first US computer built for business. And in July 1954, Boeing's 367-80 "Dash 80" jet prototype first flew. It led to the 707 airliner. We found no sourced stock figures for these frontier companies around the 1954 vote. No reliable figure.

▲ S&P one year later: up 10.2% (Dave Manuel)

2006 (Bush, Republican). Democrats took both chambers. The next day, 8 Nov, the Dow closed at a record, and the NASDAQ rose 0.4% to 2,384.94, a five-year high (Los Angeles Times, 9 Nov 2006). The day after that, the NASDAQ slipped 0.37% to 2,376.01 as traders "questioned whether a Democratic Congress would be friendly to business" (AP via Washington Post, 9 Nov 2006). By 13 Nov, tech shares had pushed the NASDAQ to 2,406.38, its highest close in more than five years (Los Angeles Times, 14 Nov 2006). Over the year, the S&P 500 rose 10.2% (Dave Manuel, and Pepperstone has +6.7% on a different close), with a worst drop of 9.4% along the way (Pepperstone).

Frontier tech then: the web 2.0 internet. In 2006, Amazon launched its S3 cloud storage service (March) and Google agreed to acquire YouTube (October). Tech led the first week, but the one-year window ended just before the 2008 crash.

When Democrats took the HOUSE only

S&P one year later: outside Dave Manuel's record

1874 (Grant, Republican). Democrats took the House for the first time since before the Civil War (House History office). It came after the Panic of 1873, which brought railroad failures and a deep depression (Washington Post, 4 Nov 2018, and Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era).

Frontier tech then: railroads, the AI of their day. The Panic of 1873 began when the bank of Jay Cooke, the main backer of the Northern Pacific Railway, failed. The crash came before the vote and helped cause the flip. Reliable stock-index figures for the months around the 1874 vote? The record is thin, and we won't make one up.

S&P one year later: outside Dave Manuel's record

1910 and 1930. Democrats won the House outright in 1910. In 1930, Republicans won a slim majority on Election Day, but 14 members-elect died before the new Congress met, and Democrats won enough of the special elections to take control in December 1931 (House History office). The 1930 vote came in the first year of the Great Depression, with radio and autos as the hot technologies. In 1910 the hot new thing was the car: Ford's Model T had come out in October 1908, and General Motors was founded the same year. By 1930, radio was the frontier, led by RCA, formed in 1919. We couldn't find sourced, election-window figures for frontier stocks in either year. The record is thin.

▲ S&P one year later: up 12.3% (Dave Manuel)

2018 (Trump, Republican). Democrats took the House and Republicans kept the Senate. On 7 Nov, the NASDAQ jumped 2.6% and the S&P 500 2.1%, its best day after a midterm since 1982 (CNBC, 7 Nov 2018). Seven weeks later, the story had flipped. On 20 Dec, the NASDAQ closed 19.7% below its August record, and Amazon, Apple, Netflix and Alphabet were each down more than 20% from their highs. CNBC pointed to steep valuations, rising borrowing costs, "increased regulatory concerns" and growth fears (CNBC, 20 Dec 2018). The S&P 500 bottomed on 24 Dec and still ended the year after the vote up 12.3% (Dave Manuel, and Pepperstone has +11.7%).

Frontier tech then: FAANG and cloud. This is the closest match to today. The frontier names fell hard after a House flip, but the reasons reported were rates and valuations, not the vote itself.

When Democrats took the SENATE only

▲ S&P one year later: up 2.0% (Dave Manuel)

1986 (Reagan, Republican). Democrats already held the House and won back the Senate. The stock market "shrugged off" the news on 5 Nov (Journal of Commerce, 5 Nov 1986). The year after looked fine at the finish line, up 2.0% (Dave Manuel, and Pepperstone has +1.1%). But in between came the October 1987 crash, with a worst drop of 33.2% (Pepperstone).

Frontier tech then: personal computers and chips. Apple's Macintosh had come out in 1984, Intel's 386 chip in 1985, and in September 1986 Compaq's Deskpro 386 became the first PC to use it. Microsoft went public in March 1986. We found no sourced election-window frontier figures. The record is thin.

For comparison: flips the OTHER way

▲ S&P one year later: up 0.8% (Dave Manuel)

1946 (Truman, Democrat). Republicans took both chambers. It came after a September crash, and the next year was the weakest on the list at +0.8% (Dave Manuel).

Frontier tech then: electronics and aviation. In February 1946, the Army unveiled ENIAC, the first general-purpose electronic computer. We found no sourced frontier stock figures for that year. No reliable figure.

▲ S&P one year later: up 26.6% (Dave Manuel)

1994 (Clinton, Democrat). Republicans took both chambers. The markets were "basically unchanged" right after, and flat into year-end (Dave Manuel, 2010). Then in 1995, the NASDAQ rose 39.9% (Dave Manuel, 2010). By early July, semiconductor stocks had "more than doubled since New Year's" (AP via Deseret News, 17 Jul 1995), and the NASDAQ topped 1,000 for the first time on 17 Jul 1995 (Los Angeles Times, 18 Jul 1995). The S&P 500 was up 26.6% a year after the vote (Dave Manuel, and Pepperstone has +27.1%).

Frontier tech then: PCs, chips and software, right before the internet boom. Intel's Pentium chip had come out in 1993, and Netscape was founded in April 1994. Was that the vote, or the Fed easing up on rate hikes? CNBC (3 Dec 2018) pointed to the Fed.

▲ S&P one year later: up 2.9% (Dave Manuel)

2010 (Obama, Democrat). Republicans took the House. The next year was up just 2.9% (Dave Manuel, and Pepperstone has +3.7%), with a 19.4% drop along the way during the 2011 debt-ceiling standoff (Pepperstone).

Frontier tech then: smartphones, tablets and cloud. Apple's first iPad had gone on sale in April 2010. We found no sourced frontier stock figures for the year after the vote. No reliable figure.

When Republicans kept control

▲ S&P one year later: up 16.0% (Dave Manuel)

2002 (Bush). Republicans kept the House and won the Senate. The S&P 500 was up 16.0% a year later (Dave Manuel, and Pepperstone has +14.9%). It came off the dot-com bear market low of 9 Oct 2002, a month before the vote.

Frontier tech then: the internet companies that survived the dot-com crash, such as Amazon, eBay and Google.

The comparison table

One-year figures are from Dave Manuel (21 Oct 2026) and Pepperstone (1 Nov 2026), which use different start and end closes. Worst-drop figures are from Pepperstone. Years before 1950 are outside Pepperstone's study. Frontier notes are from the contemporary reports cited above.

Play 3: So what could it mean for AI?

Here's what the film shows, and what it doesn't:

Play 4: The talking heads, by scenario

First, the odds, which aren't results. JPMorgan (via CNBC, 2 Nov) put a Democratic sweep at 66%, Democrats taking only the House at 26%, Republicans keeping both at 7% and Democrats taking only the Senate at 1%. UBS Global Wealth Management (via Reuters, 3 Nov) put it at 50% sweep, 40% House-only and 10% Republicans keeping both.

Democrats take the House only

Democrats take the Senate only

Democrats take both

Republicans keep both

Whoever takes the committee

In 1995 and 2018, interest rates moved the frontier more than the vote did. Could the same be true this time?

Final whistle

The rules committee may flip tonight. The film says the league has kept playing after every flip since 1946, and the frontier players have taken the wildest swings, both ways. But the film is only 20 games long, the railroad and radio tapes are missing, and nobody has watched this season's ending yet.

What to watch:

So when the committee changes, does the game change too? Or does it just get louder?

Sources

Midterm history: the S&P record

Contemporary reporting

2026 election and markets

Voices

Our scoreboard

Get the Pulse